[x]

deviantART

 

A house divided!

Mon Feb 11, 2008, 2:51 PM
  • Mood: Confused
  • Playing: Pokeymans
I've been kind of curious as to how houses in Harry Potter work. They're supposed to reflect major traits in the students, but they also rely heavily on choice. Harry was put into Gryffindor because he chose to be there, even though he could have been in either Gryffindor or Slytherin. Hermione chose Gryffindor, even though she could have been in either that or Ravenclaw. Neville is the same way. We see him come to be this brave, leader character (more than Harry, IMO), but in the beginning it was his choice that primarily placed him in his house.

So now I'm curious about Ron. Throughout the books, Ron is seem as extremely cowardly. He has to be coerced into doing anything with Harry and Hermione that sounds even remotely dangerous. Especially in the second book, I get the feeling he was only in the car because of his brothers, or in the woods because Harry wanted him to come. In the last book, which should have been a big moment for Ron, he manages to abandon his friends and run away because he doesn't feel like doing it anymore. He comes back, yes, but not out of bravery. In all 7 books, Ron is shown to be a very loyal character, and nowhere near brave. Yet instead of Hufflepuff, whose main attribute is loyalty, he's in Gryffindor.

So I'm wondering about how the houses are picked. I guess it doesn't really matter what your personality is like, because you'll end up in the house of your choosing anyway. This makes me wonder why the Sorting Hat even exists. Most likely, JKR made a mess of her Ronnie bits and couldn't really fix them before the series was over.:\

...This has nothing to do with my questions on how Ron ever became and Auror when he was so shitty at magic.

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0

Obviously Ron is secretly a gary stu.
This is how he ended up in Gryffindor and also how he's an auror.

--
"She tried, again and again, to explain what being a 'prostitute' was. It somehow involved making others happy by being lovable. I still do not really understand."
wut

CRAZY PEOPLE
put too much thought into teh books.

--
You can complain because roses have thorns, or you can rejoice that thorns have roses.
But that makes no sense because Gary Stu's have either a worse or better family life. :(

--
You can't fake this funk
Your face is crazy

--
You can't fake this funk
He's incognito. His family is his disguise.

--
"She tried, again and again, to explain what being a 'prostitute' was. It somehow involved making others happy by being lovable. I still do not really understand."
Dear god. He was born a poor black child.

--
You can't fake this funk
Precisely.

--
"She tried, again and again, to explain what being a 'prostitute' was. It somehow involved making others happy by being lovable. I still do not really understand."
:iconohfuckplz:

--
You can complain because roses have thorns, or you can rejoice that thorns have roses.
Any well balanced person shouldn't lean too heavily towards any of the houses, but Harry was placed in Gryffindor not simply for his "choice" but the act of making that choice was an act of loyalty to his friends, thus making more qualified for the house in which he was placed. Hermione too has an essence of compassion and loyalty that presides over her logic and reason. The strongest traits will decide which house a student is to be placed in. The act of making the decisions they made more qualified them for the house.

There is no "cowardly" house, and I don't remember a "requirement" to be in Gryffindor having much to do with bravery, although it does have to do with courage, which I would require a bit of a different concept. Even Ron has stood brave in the most dire of situations when his strength was needed. I have not read the seventh book (OH SHAME THE FANGIRLS WILL KILL ME NOW), so I cannot really vouch for what he did in the seventh book, but I do know one thing; he wasn't placed into Gryffindor in the seventh book. The hat has made mistakes.

Hufflepuff focuses on loyalty, fairness, and tolerance. I don't think Ron is a very fair or tolerant individual... perhaps much more the opposite than that in many occasions. I think he is rather misplaced no matter what house you put him in.

The act of choosing which house you wish to be in and why reveals certain traits of your character.

--
Elwood's Blues

Journal History

Site Map